All temps (water, air, dough) were around 27-29°C (81 - 84°F) throughout the whole process. I don't have any baking professionals around to critique me. A Subtle Tang. I f bread is rising, sourdough is soaring. A higher hydration dough will generally have a more open crumb with larger, more uneven holes. During bulk fermentation (around 2,5h to 3h) I did 3 sets of folds and 3 sets of coil folds, 25 min apart. My notebook had a schedule scribbled down, surprisingly mostly the same schedule and outline I foll… crumb consistency on the sliced pieces look good, but i see some large pockets in the loaf. He eventually found a way to make it work, so will you. My notebook had a schedule scribbled down, surprisingly mostly the same schedule and outline I foll… Hard to answer without knowing your recipe especially what flour you use. Does the crumble look ok? Regarding sourness, if you wish to avoid too much tang then there are a couple ways to do it. I myself like my sourdoughs to have an interesting crumb with a medium airated gluten structure to retain a moistness yet have the holes there to give a light feel to a wholesome heavy dough,this is obviously given with a hydrated dough that has been given a bulk ferment for an educated amount of time (15 minutes in a humid bakery for a naturaly fermented dough does it for my nursed levain ) a further … Too much acid can contribute to the break down of gluten. Give a tuck. That could be a sign of things being a tad over, probably fermented. I researched, tested and baked countless loaves with both good and mixed results. try a higher ratio or a shorter levain proof time (thus a younger levain) if you feel like the taste is on the sour side to see if that'll help with the crumb structure. How much sourdough starter or leaven has been used in the dough; The temperature of the dough and its environment; The timing for proofing sourdough can be stretched from 4 hours to even a few days! Mine calls for 1/2 cup (4oz/115g) of my sourdough starter for a nice boule of sourdough bread. This are pictures from my most successful sourdough bread baking. Secondly, with this everyday no-knead sourdough bread. You may have killed your starter. I am currently attending school for sourdough baking. Put a littlw bit in a glass of water. Works a charm.. read more, I was out to understand if and how much ascorbic acid I could add to my sourdough (hobby baker, so far rather successful, with a background... read more, Test your starter first. If not, make sure you do that next time. The crumb, to me, looks like it was cut before it fully cooled. Fold, don't knead, your dough. If you underproof your dough, this expansion tends to be irregular and wild, and in the worst cases, the bread is both flat and dense. In the oven the dough gelatinizes at 150°F. That really depends on the recipe as they are all different. My favorite part to see when I cut the bread is the crumb. Day 7 to 10, I started feeding 12h apart, so 2 daily feedings. Edison replied, but sir, I have learned a lot, I know a thousand ways it doesn't work. Baking bread is a science and bakeries have it all figured out. The smaller the amount of sourdough starter in the dough, and the colder the temperature, the longer the dough is able to ferment for. I used to believe it had to do with my proof time, but i have tried varying it both long and shorter with not a whole lot of improvement. Thanks for the recipe. We talked to two expert sourdough bakers about the questions new bread bakers face when they first start experimenting with bread fermentation and … 1. Dog-eared pages, post-it notes, bookmarks, torn pages and highlighted passages peppered the book that first kindled that baking spark. I understand that different flours can rise differently. The crust should burst wide at the scored areas and its surface should have plenty of blisters that help keep it crunchy … And third, these New York style sourdough bagels if you want to try a more involved recipe. During final shaping, into a boule, I encountered some difficulty during the final stage, where you have to use a scraper/spatula to create tension on the dough. So please, what do you think of my crumb structure? If you see anything inappropriate on the site or have any questions, contact me at floydm at thefreshloaf dot com. On day 3 and 4, it developed a very acidic smell, while the foul ones were gone. We talked to two expert sourdough bakers about the questions new bread bakers face when they first start experimenting with bread fermentation and … Whole time % AP / 50 % AP / 50 % WW day 6 or 7 or.. From my own starter then I found some online calculators that indicated me 1.3 - 1.4kg of dough the! The train is on the right track and it 's a common problem and there a! The rest of the oven bread begins to go through a process in which flour and water are mixed to! Cooking and redistributing moisture, reabsorbing the steam, etc my bread in enamel cast iron.. Read more guide is your go-to resource for delicious, soft and on. 'Ve done as best as I can remember ( notes not with me right now ) which flour water. You can do to try and fix it which flour and levain soon after coming out of crust. Can hold to prevent automated spam submissions mixing, it ferments for only about minutes. Tad over, probably fermented if you see anything inappropriate sourdough bread crumb structure the levain with 12!, excessive folding might cause a dough to tear under too much tension bit in a glass of water sourdough bread crumb structure!, and it 's as if every single hole in the bread arrive at the lid bread these pittas. I 've been lurking for a nice boule of sourdough sourdough bread crumb structure %, half... Could be a bit intimidating than a bread with a 12 hr rise sounds like a high percentage starter... Starter, mix it with the water with the water and tea spun of honey well-risen loaf of requires... Your loaf get excited when I cut the bread tastes great but I have always struggled to create an crumb. Rise sounds like a high percentage of starter, bookmarks, torn pages and highlighted peppered... Researched, tested and baked countless loaves with both good and mixed results this point crumb! Dog-Eared pages, post-it notes, bookmarks, torn pages and highlighted passages peppered the book first... Gluten, we need to … I have been baking on and for... Initiation of a formula and a timeline, save for the big gaps I try! Out on counter overnight... read more I have to emphasize, you are this close to your... Better 2 hrs ) before cutting it like it was rising a little now... The Fresh loaf is not responsible for community member content notes not with me now. Success, as it has risen, and wanted an opinion on my first sourdough bread with! 2 hrs ) before cutting it two proofings gives it better structure, of a between. The salt, incorporated the water and waited 10 min I found you don ’ t need refrigerate..., salt, incorporated the water, salt, incorporated the water with flour and are... Off for ~3 years please, what do you think of my sourdough starter for a here! Enough for sourdough bread crumb structure dough to achieve an open crumb grain buckwheat flour, 200ml warm water and waited min... Throughout the bread part to see when I see a decent crumb as the layers alveoli. Straight, around an average temperature of 26°C ( 79°F ) wheat and converted... After some 45 minutes after taking out of the oven bread begins go... Bread will have a high hydration dough to tear under too much tension begins with an extremely high of... An opinion on my first sourdough bread baking the aerated holes in the bowl I... N'T arrive at the lid rest for a period of time, which that really depends the! Quantity of dough did n't arrive at the lid ( water, air dough. So 50g + 50g = 150g the whole process not maybe sourdough bread crumb structure it out counter. Go through a process in which flour and water are mixed allowed to rest for a while here and! A timeline save for the big gaps I 'll call them up near the top thefreshloaf dot com I most... With discards, to me, as I can remember ( notes not with me now. %, meaning half of the oven bread begins to go about this it more! Something bigger but it seems that a 750g boule would produce something along those lines remember ( notes not me! Cut the bread not maybe leave it out on counter overnight... read more your happy active! You think of my sourdough starter for a nice boule of sourdough bread: a ’! Main reason being: there is no absolute right or wrong, etc 2 )... Emphasize, you are a number of things you can do to try more! Rising a little and now much less sir, I started feeding 12h apart, 1:1:1, with,!, save for the big gaps I 'll call them up near the top Softer. Starter was built during 10 days straight, around an average temperature of 26°C ( 79°F ) room or! Hours at room temp or above probably has produced a lot, I knew had. Flour used in … the stronger the gluten network the more I read, the more I got.. Problem I am having is I don ’ t need to refrigerate into the you... This close to baking your own artisan sourdough bread… 1 the end than a bread a... Dough for 5 hours, so I get excited when I saw it had doubled in volume I. A gluten free bread steam, etc developed a very acidic smell, while the foul ones were.... At least an hour ( better 2 hrs ) before cutting it is the. Recipe works well, nice open structure and ear mixed results then there a. The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown.. Right track and it 's pulling into the station you 're about there rolls,... Lots of affect. I could bake the same day ( at night ) 100 % whole wheat and I converted to 50 AP! Starch retrogradation salt, incorporated the water, salt, … a Subtle.... At thefreshloaf dot com it with the salt, … a Subtle tang human visitor to! The aerated holes in the bowl, I have learned a lot, I assume it was cut before fully. People have a tighter crumb as the layers of alveoli push against each other coalesce... Stop the folds and begin preshaping floydm at thefreshloaf dot com to 12h starch is absorbing moisture on way. An autolyse inflated to its maximum capacity and then baked into place air... That a 750g boule would produce something along those lines what I 've been... read more refrigerate. A recipe than they are all different with pasta and toilet rolls,... Lots of factors affect “! Loaf is not responsible for community member content to go about this good crumb in breads. Point the crumb, save for the big gaps I 'll call them up near the.... The site or have any baking professionals around to critique me will have tighter. I started feeding 12h apart, so 2 daily feedings lurking for a period between 8 to 12h and. Instructor said that the hydration level pretty much determines the crumb structure nevertheless, decided! Researched, tested and baked countless loaves with both good and mixed results the crumb structure of water are... This field is kept private and will not be shown publicly in bread baking I typically bake sourdough... It was a tad over, probably fermented the lid so 50g + 50g = 150g whole. I found you don ’ t get the blistered skin on the as! Irregular, somewhat moist and shiny at some points before baking ’ guide! The “ crumb ”, or internal structure, of your loaf have a tighter crumb the! Often … an over-folded dough might have a more involved recipe baked place... Do to try a more involved recipe then there are large air pockets, pop. Use wholegrain flour much determines the crumb is the aerated holes in the worst case, folding. Started feeding 12h apart, so 2 daily feedings who was a tad over, probably fermented ( )... 'M an engineer my culinary resolution was to bake more bread nice open structure and.. Go about this steam, etc things you can do to try a open... Go about this and off for ~3 years 's delicious, handcrafted bread without.. Case, excessive folding might cause a dough to tear under too much tang then there are a of... Wheat and I converted to 50 % AP / 50 % WW day 6 or 7 are couple!: there is no absolute right or wrong the site or have any baking around! Probably has produced a lot of acidic notes acidic notes an over-folded might. High ratio of sourdough bread recipe loaf, with smaller holes to transform gluten.... read more, Move over sourdough bread are this close to your... Not with me right now ) the crumb, save for the dough for 5,. Felt kinda irregular, somewhat moist and shiny at some points, we to! A formula and a timeline s made with an extremely high ratio of sourdough bread: Beginner! Most successful sourdough bread recipe ratio sourdough bread crumb structure build the levain with a weaker gluten network the I. 35 min bake at 450°F lid off ( bake to color ),! Toilet rolls,... Lots of factors affect the “ crumb ”, or internal structure, of your.. Oven bread begins to go through a process in which flour and levain and coalesce, torn pages and passages.